Order Now!

Gaines Street Pies

It's where it's at!

Pizzas, Calzone, Sandwiches, Salads, Wraps, Desserts and BEER!

We've got gluten free and vegan cheeses!

Open seven days a week! Sunday through Thursday, from 11am to Midnight. Friday and Saturday, from 11am to 3am.

Phone number: 850-765-9275
507 West Gaines Street
Tallahassee, FL, 32303
U.S.A
Appetizers GARLIC KNOTS $3.50 6 STONE-BAKED, PUFFY WONDERS OF GARLICKY, BUTTERY GOODNESS TOPPED WITH ROMANO CHEESE AND SERVED WITH A SIDE OF OUR HOMEMADE MARINARA. HUMMUS PLATE $7.45 A GENEROUS PORTION OF HUMMUS SERVED WITH OUR FRESHLY BAKED PITA BREAD, CUCUMBERS, ROASTED RED PEPPERS, KALAMATA OLIVES AND FETA CHEESE. CHEESY BREAD $6.95 OUR 10” GARLIC-BUTTERED, HAND-TOSSED DOUGH LOADED WITH PROVOLONE, MOZZARELLA, CHEDDAR, AND ROMANO. SERVED WITH A SIDE OF OUR HOMEMADE RANCH FOR DIPPING. CAPRESE SALAD $7.45 RICH LAYERS OF TOMATO AND FRESH MOZZARELLA TOPPED WITH FRESH BASIL AND OUR HOMEMADE BALSAMIC REDUCTION. BACON WRAPPED JALAPEÑO POPPERS $7.25 6 FRESH JALAPEÑO POPPERS STUFFED WITH SAVORY CREAM CHEESE AND CHEDDAR, WRAPPED WITH BACON AND BAKED TO PERFECTION. SERVED WITH HOMEMADE RANCH FOR DIPPING. SPINACH ARTICHOKE DIP $7.45 FRESH, HOT AND DELICIOUS! MADE IN HOUSE AND SERVED WITH OUR FRESHLY BAKED PITA BREAD. Salads COBB SALAD $7.95 A BED OF CRISP ROMAINE LETTUCE TOPPED WITH FRESH CHICKEN, BACON, TOMATO, CUCUMBER, EGG, AVOCADO, BLEU CHEESE CRUMBLES AND OUR HOMEMADE RANCH. ARUGULA APPLE SALAD $7.95 ARUGULA, GREEN APPLES, ROASTED FIG, GOAT CHEESE AND CANDIED WALNUTS, SERVED WITH OUR HOUSE VINAIGRETTE DRESSING. SXSW $6.95 CRISP ROMAINE LETTUCE TOPPED WITH BELL PEPPERS, BLACK BEANS, AVOCADO, SALSA, CORN, CHEDDAR AND SOUR CREAM, SERVED WITH OUR HOMEMADE RANCH. ADD CHICKEN FOR $2. STAY CLASSY CAESAR $6.25 CRISP ROMAINE TOSSED IN OUR HOMEMADE CAESAR DRESSING AND ROMANO, ONIONS, TOMATO AND OUR FRESHLY BAKED CROUTONS. ADD CHICKEN FOR $2. SOUTHERN STYLE GREEK $7.95 A BED OF CRISP ROMAINE, FRESH TOMATOES, KALAMATA OLIVES, ONIONS, FETA, AND A SCOOP OF OUR HOMEMADE POTATO SALAD, SERVED WITH OUR SIGNATURE SUN DRIED TOMATO GREEK DRESSING. SPINACH SALAD $7.95 FRESH SPINACH, TOMATOES, EGG, BACON, ONIONS AND FETA, SERVED WITH OUR HOUSE VINAIGRETTE.
Pizza Specialty Pies MY, MY! BREAKFAST PIE! BACON, HAM, EGG, CHEDDAR, BELL PEPPERS AND THINLY SLICED POTATOES (TRY IT WITH SALSA OR SRIRACHA). BREAKFAST SERVED ALL DAY! THE MCBURGER PIZZA BAKED WITH GROUND BEEF, CHEDDAR CHEESE, KETCHUP, MUSTARD AND PICKLES, THEN TOPPED WITH LETTUCE AND DICED ONION. BACON BLEUS FRESH, ALL NATURAL BACON, BLEU CHEESE CRUMBLES AND ROASTED RED PEPPERS. MO ROCKIN’ A BASIL PESTO BASE TOPPED WITH CRISPY BREADED EGGPLANT, ONIONS, FETA, FRESH GARLIC AND BASIL, AND CRACKED BLACK PEPPER. THE MITCHKA A SAVORY BLEND OF CRISPY BREADED EGGPLANT, ITALIAN SAUSAGE, FRESH GARLIC, ROMANO AND MOZZARELLA. PESTO CHICKEN A HOMEMADE BASIL PESTO BASE TOPPED WITH FRESH TOMATOES, ONIONS AND TENDER CHICKEN BREAST. THE SAUCY MINX OUR MARINARA SAUCE BASE TOPPED WITH OUR DELICIOUS HOMEMADE MEATBALLS, RICH RICOTTA CHEESE DOLLOPS, SEASONAL BELL PEPPERS AND FRESH BASIL. BBQ CHICKEN PIZZA LIGHT TOMATO SAUCE, HOUSE BBQ SAUCE, TENDER CHICKEN BREAST, ONIONS, ROASTED CORN AND SPICY JALAPEÑOS! GUY ON A BUFFALO... CHICKEN OUR CREAMY HOMEMADE RANCH DRESSING BASE TOPPED WITH TENDER SLICES OF CHICKEN BREAST, BLUE CHEESE CRUMBLES, BUFFALO SAUCE AND GREEN ONIONS. THE ONE WITH EVERYTHING ON IT THE AGE OLD COMBINATION OF PEPPERONI, SAUSAGE, HAM, BELL PEPPERS, ONIONS, MUSHROOMS, AND BLACK OLIVES. DEREK SANDERS IS A VEGETARIAN FRESH TOMATO, MUSHROOMS, BLACK OLIVES, SEASONAL BELL PEPPERS, ONIONS, FRESH SPINACH AND GARLIC. FIGURE FOUR AN OLIVE OIL BASE TOPPED WITH MOZZARELLA AND CRUMBLED GOAT CHEESE, ROASTED FIG, CAPICOLA AND FRESH GARLIC. MARGHERITA MAYHEM A LIGHT TOMATO SAUCE BASE TOPPED WITH FRESH MOZZARELLA, PECORINO ROMANO, GARLIC, BASIL, TOMATOES, OLIVE OIL AND CRACKED BLACK PEPPER. EL GUAPO A BLACK BEAN SAUCE BASE TOPPED WITH YOUR CHOICE OF CHICKEN OR GROUND BEEF, CILANTRO, ONIONS, AVOCADO, JALAPEÑOS, SALSA AND SOUR CREAM. THIS IS ANIMAL PIZZA LOADED WITH PEPPERONI, ITALIAN SAUSAGE, BACON, HAM AND GROUND BEEF. THE WHITE ALBUM A RICH RICOTTA BASE WITH A BLEND OF ROMANO AND MOZZARELLA, TOPPED WITH TOMATOES, ONIONS, FRESH GARLIC, BASIL, ARUGULA AND A TRUFFLE OIL SPRITZ. THE METAL MIKE OUR HOUSE RANCH DRESSING BASE WITH BACON, CHICKEN, GARLIC, GREEN ONIONS AND A HIT OF SRIRACHA! BRUNO SAMMARTINO PEPPERONI, HAM, CAPICOLA, DICED PEPPERONCINIS AND FRESH GARLIC. FOXY CLEOPATRA A SAVORY HUMMUS BASE, ARTICHOKES, ROASTED RED PEPPERS, SWIRLS OF OUR HOUSE MADE SUN DRIED TOMATO SAUCE, FETA CHEESE AND KALAMATA OLIVES. ADD CHICKEN OR EGGPLANT $2. Build your own TOPPINGS: PEPPERONI, ITALIAN SAUSAGE, GROUND BEEF, HAM, BACON, CHICKEN, MEATBALLS, MUSHROOMS, ONIONS, BELL PEPPERS, ROASTED RED PEPPERS, TOMATOES, PESTO, GARLIC, ARTICHOKE, PEPPERONCINIS, KALAMATA OLIVES, BLACK OLIVES, PINEAPPLE, SPINACH, EGGPLANT, ROASTED CORN, JALAPEÑOS, BLACK BEANS, RICOTTA, FETA, CHEDDAR, SOUR CREAM, BASIL, CILANTRO, THYME, PILI PILI OIL. PREMIUM TOPPINGS: CAPICOLA, ROASTED FIG, TRUFFLE OIL, SUN DRIED TOMATOES, AVOCADO, ANCHOVIES, GOAT CHEESE, FRESH MOZZARELLA, GORGONZOLA, VEGAN CHEESE.
Sandwiches CHICKEN PARMESAN SUB TENDER SLICED CHICKEN BREAST TOPPED WITH OUR HOMEMADE MARINARA AND A BLEND OF MOZZARELLA AND PARMESAN CHEESES. MEATBALL PARMESAN SUB OUR SAVORY HOMEMADE MEATBALLS TOPPED WITH MARINARA, MOZZARELLA AND PARMESAN. CHICKEN CAESAR SUB TENDER CHICKEN BREAST, MOZZARELLA CHEESE, CRISP ROMAINE LETTUCE AND ONIONS TOSSED IN ROMANO AND OUR HOUSE CAESAR DRESSING . EGGPLANT PARMESAN SUB CRISPY BREADED EGGPLANT TOPPED WITH HOMEMADE MARINARA, MOZZARELLA AND PARMESAN. NEWSOM’S OWN ITALIAN SUB CAPICOLA, HAM, PEPPERONI, ARUGULA, TOMATO, ONION AND OIL & VINEGAR TOPPED WITH A DELICIOUS BLEND OF PROVOLONE, MOZZARELLA AND ROMANO CHEESES. MR. WRIGHT’S 8” SAUSAGE... AND PEPPERS... SUB SAVORY ITALIAN SAUSAGE WITH A BLEND OF SEASONAL BELL PEPPERS, MARINARA SAUCE, MOZZARELLA AND PARMESAN CHEESES. Wraps THE HERO SAVORY SLICES OF CHICKEN BREAST, FRESH SPINACH LEAVES, KALAMATA OLIVES, ONIONS, MOZZARELLA AND FETA CHEESES AND OUR HOMEMADE SUNDRIED TOMATO DRESSING. ADD HUMMUS FOR $1 OR SUB FOR CHICKEN. BBQ CHICKEN WRAP FRESH CHICKEN BREAST, LETTUCE, TOMATO, ONIONS AND ROASTED CORN TOPPED WITH MOZZARELLA AND CHEDDAR CHEESES, AND DRIZZLED WITH OUR HOUSE BBQ SAUCE. LOOK! MEXICO! YOUR CHOICE OF GROUND BEEF OR CHICKEN BREAST, STUFFED WITH SALSA, OUR HOMEMADE RANCH, AVOCADO AND ONIONS, AND THEN TOPPED WITH ROMAINE LETTUCE AND SOUR CREAM. BUFFALO BLEU FRESH CHICKEN BREAST, LETTUCE, ONIONS, BLEU CHEESE CRUMBLES, MOZZARELLA AND PROVOLONE, COVERED IN BUFFALO SAUCE AND RANCH DRESSING. THE SPINS FRESH SPINACH, ARTICHOKES, TOMATOES AND ONIONS TOPPED WITH A SAVORY BLEND OF MOZZARELLA AND CHEDDAR CHEESES. Calzones BUILD YOUR OWN STUFFED WITH A RICH BLEND OF RICOTTA AND MOZZARELLA CHEESES AND ONE TOPPING OF YOUR CHOICE. 10” $8.50 14” $12.25 ADDITIONAL TOPPINGS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . $1.50 $2.00 PREMIUM TOPPINGS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . $2.25 $2.75 CHICKEN FLORENTINE . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . $10.95 $15.50 TENDER SLICED CHICKEN BREAST, RICOTTA, MOZZARELLA AND OUR HOUSE MADE SPINACH ARTICHOKE DIP! sOFTdrinks & tEA... $1.79 Desserts THE CHEESECAKE CALZONE $8.50 AN ENTIRE SLICE OF NEW YORK STYLE CHEESECAKE AND A WHOLE BAR OF CREAMY MILK CHOCOLATE STUFFED INTO A 10” CALZONE AND BAKED TO PERFECTION. APPLE PIE PIZZA $6.95 OUR HAND-TOSSED RICOTTA CHEESE STUFFED CRUST WITH A OUR BROWN SUGAR BUTTER BASE, TOPPED WITH THINLY SLICED CINNAMON APPLES AND CANDIED WALNUTS, THEN DRIZZLED WITH DECADENT CARAMEL. SNICKERDOODLE PIE $4.95 OUR HAND-TOSSED 10” DOUGH LAYERED WITH A DELICIOUS BLEND OF RICH, VELVETY BUTTER AND CINNAMON AND SUGAR, AND THEN TOPPED WITH WARM DOLLOPS OF OUR HOMEMADE CREAM CHEESE ICING.